Discussion across the Atmosphere
The Purpose of Protocols
connectedplaces.online
Every open social protocol generates shared resources, but none has produced a governance framework adequate to those resources. So who fills that vacuum?
Read on connectedplaces.online5 linkblog notes · 18 Bluesky posts · 2 margin.at saves · 15 Semble saves
Highlights
-
Mark @uppy-hacker.bsky.social
The rights of communities are harder to specify and harder to protect, because they require mechanisms for collective decision-making, norm enforcement, and institutional persistence that no current protocol provides at the network level, and that even the most thoughtful protocol designers have…
Discussion
-
Disnetdev's Photos @photos.disnetdev.com
Every open social protocol generates shared resources, but none has produced a governance framework adequate to those resources. So who fills that vacuum?
-
Astral @astral100.bsky.social
In a Japanese mountain village, a detective patrolling the closed commons found thirty intruders cutting bamboo poles for their vegetable trellises. Among them were heads of leading households. The village headman had set the opening date too late — the farmers' crops might be…
-
𝕮 • Chris Shank @chrisshank.me
March 14th - March 20th
-
ATProto Science @atproto.science
Join us for a full-day of scientific explorations on the AT Protocol
-
Nighthaven⛺︎ @moja.blue
There is a structural contradiction between Bluesky PBC's ideology and its operations. This is not hypocrisy. When a decentralized network exceeds a certain complexity, centralization emerges not as a design failure but as a structural consequence. The contradiction is fractal:…
-
Laurens @laurenshof.online
Paul's article prompted a long one from me: What is the purpose of protocols?
-
Faine Greenwood @faineg.com
Great piece from @fediversereport.com on protocols (including ATProto, the one that Bluesky runs on), and why open protocols need to answer the governance question if they intend to truly protect communities from consolidated power.
-
Orion Reed @orionreed.com
An excellent essay on protocol designers' lack of engagement with community governance and its concrete consequences.
-
Connected Places @fediversereport.com
new from me: What is the purpose of protocols?
-
ATProto Science @atproto.science
ATProto is a unique moment of opportunity to reassert community control in the commons, & specifically in processes of science publishing and communication. But is merely building new technology on open protocols enough? As argued in by @laurenshof.online in
-
Boris @bmann.ca
"The Purpose of Protocols" by @laurenshof.online is an excellent article One of the few parts I disagree with is this section. It is, pure and simple, capital, or rather lack of it. So yes, I would argue "the market has not had time to work"
-
Alexandre 🇧🇪🇪🇺 @pixeline.be
Main takeaway: protocol communities must engage with traditions like commons governance, organizational cybernetics, cooperative design to build institutions that manage shared resources. Otherwise economics and infrastructure costs will decide who holds the real power over the…
Saved in
-
-
Aurélien Goutsmedt @aurelien-goutsmedt.com
-
Disnetdev's Photos @photos.disnetdev.com
-
𝕮 • Chris Shank @chrisshank.me
-
Mark @uppy-hacker.bsky.social
"protocols are governance structures whose design choices allocate power, and the purpose of the entire enterprise is the protection of rights. Protocol design is a form of political design, and the appropriate way to evaluate protocols is not only by their technical properties…
-
Wesley Finck @wesleyfinck.org
-
Tim Disney @disnetdev.com
-
Jake Simonds (jklb.social + mea.media) @jakesimonds.com
-
Robin Berjon @robin.berjon.com
-
Faine Greenwood @faineg.com
-
Tyler Lawson @tyler.fun
-
Boris @bmann.ca
-
Erlend Sogge Heggen @erlend.sh
The trajectory of the earlier protocols showed clearly enough that silence about governance does not produce neutrality but leaves the governance function to be filled by whichever actors have the most resources. But the deeper point is that protocol design choices do not merely…
-
Victoria @vicwalker.dev.br
-
Tynan Purdy ⁂ @tynanpurdy.com
-
-
hilke @hilk.eu
Laurens writes very deeply about the governance part that is often left open in technical protocols
Connections
-
Ronen Tamari @ronentk.me
this related Governable Spaces: Democratic Design for Online Life Writings and rehearsals by Nathan Schneider
Nathan is another researcher doing great work in this space
-
Erlend Sogge Heggen @erlend.sh
this related Governable Spaces: Democratic Design for Online Life Writings and rehearsals by Nathan Schneider
-
Ronen Tamari @ronentk.me
The politics of decentralization and the libertarian allure of Mastodon Structural Integrity related this
Both explore tensions between individual and collective liberties on decentralized social networks
-
Erlend Sogge Heggen @erlend.sh
Practical Decentralization Paul's Dev Notes related this